Videos

NJ Asks Judge to Pause Suppressor Ban Case Until SCOTUS Rules on Vermont

November 20, 2026

New Jersey wants to freeze a federal lawsuit over its total suppressor ban while the Supreme Court sorts out an unrelated AR-15 case, and in a video from Armed Scholar, the host walks through why the state thinks that's the smart move and why the plaintiffs say it's just stalling.

Snapshot

The video breaks down New Jersey's motion to stay the Padua suppressor case until the Supreme Court decides Vermont v. Cook County, an AR-15 ban case the state believes could reshape how courts analyze "arms," common use, and historical tradition under Bruen. Armed Scholar lays out both sides' briefing and notes the judge, Karen Williams, now has to decide whether to pause the case or let it proceed.

Key points

  • The case at issue: Padua challenges New Jersey's outright ban on buying or possessing suppressors, with plaintiffs including the Second Amendment Foundation, NRA, ASA, and NJRPC.
  • New Jersey's argument: The state says Vermont could clarify what counts as a protected arm and how common use fits into the legal test, so ruling now risks a wasted do-over.
  • Plaintiffs push back: They argue the Third Circuit already set binding precedent, didn't wait for Vermont in the prior NJRPC case, and that every month of delay keeps an unconstitutional ban enforced.
  • Padua's personal stake: Plaintiff Mr. Padua says he suffers military-related hearing loss and needs a suppressor; New Jersey counters that commercial hearing protection is a sufficient alternative.
  • What's next: Briefing is closed, and Judge Williams must rule before the Supreme Court's December 2 oral arguments in Vermont, which the video says now loom over the timing of this entire dispute.

Quick take

Armed Scholar treats this less as a suppressor ruling and more as a procedural chess match that could decide how fast — or slow — suppressor rights litigation moves nationwide, and he invites viewers to weigh in on whether the stay should be granted.

Watch the full video: Armed Scholar