How the SIG P226 Nearly Beat Beretta for the Army's M9 Contract
James Reeves of TFB TV traveled to SIG's factory in Neuhausen, Switzerland, to handle an actual XM9 trials pistol, one of only 30 made, guided through the company's museum by longtime SIG employee Rico.
Snapshot
The video traces the SIG P226's run at the U.S. military's XM9 trials against the Beretta 92, the contest that replaced the aging .45 ACP 1911. Reeves explains how engineering tweaks, new ammunition and revised testing turned an early reliability embarrassment into a standout 1984 performance, while Rico walks through the surviving test guns and their sheet-metal slide construction.
Key points
- Early failure: In 1981 testing, the P226 managed only 209 mean rounds between failures, barely better than the worn-out 1911s it was meant to replace.
- Late turnaround: By the 1984 final trial, fixes to the gun, ammo and test methodology pushed the P226 to 2,877 mean rounds between failures, well ahead of the Beretta 92's 1,750.
- Price wasn't the deciding factor: SIG quoted $176 per pistol versus Beretta's $179, but Beretta's magazines were cheaper, and since the Army needed four magazines per pistol, Beretta's total package came in about $3 million cheaper.
- Rare survivors: Rico tells Reeves only 30 XM9 test pistols exist, with just two on display at SIG's museum and the rest believed to still be with the Army.
- Build evolution: Reeves compares his original 1988 West German sheet-metal-slide P226 to a 2004-05 model with an American stainless slide, showing how production shifted from Germany to New Hampshire over time.
Quick take
This one's worth a watch for anyone who geeks out on firearms history rather than just spec sheets. Reeves does a good job showing how close that contract really came down, and getting Rico on camera to explain the sheet-metal slide construction is a nice bonus most reviews skip entirely.
Watch the full video: TFB TV