Videos

Why the T48, America's FAL, Lost to the T44

November 18, 2026

Jonathan Ferguson of the Royal Armouries pulls three rare T48 rifles out of the collection to explain why the American version of the FN FAL never made it into GI hands. He lines up an FN-built example against a Harrington & Richardson-built one, pointing out the small changes that separated the two factories' work and the bigger story of why the U.S. passed on the rifle entirely.

Snapshot

Ferguson traces the T48 back to the Canadian-pattern FAL adopted in 1954, showing how American engineers converted the metric design to imperial measurements and added their own touches. He argues the rifle performed well enough in trials to stand alongside the competing T44, but lost out for reasons that go beyond raw performance.

Key points

  • Two manufacturers, two handguards: Ferguson shows how High Standard's early prototypes gave way to production runs split between FN in Belgium and Harrington & Richardson in Worcester, Massachusetts, each using a different handguard pattern.
  • Distinct American hardware: He points out the bar-style cocking handle on the H&R guns, the US patent flash suppressor, an oddly placed sling swivel groove, and the squared-off charger guide that lets troops load with 10-round clips or magazines.
  • Numbers from the Blake Stevens books: Ferguson cites figures of 2,270 "FAL Canada pattern" rifles and 833 "bonafide" T48s, plus 200 heavy-barrel T48 E1 automatic rifles built for trials.
  • Mixed trial results: He notes the T48 struggled in sand and in at least one Arctic test, exposing the FAL's known vulnerability to dirt before later Commonwealth models addressed it with bolt carrier modifications.
  • Adoption outcome: Despite solid showings at Fort Benning, Ferguson says the Army ultimately chose the lighter Garand-descended T44 over the FAL.

Quick take

This is a close, hands-on comparison for anyone curious about the FAL's path through American trials, with Ferguson handling genuine H&R and FN-marked T48s side by side and calling out details most collectors never get to see.

Watch the full video: Royal Armouries