Videos

Fifth Circuit Revisits Felon Gun Ban's Commerce Clause Foundations

November 20, 2026

A felon-in-possession case out of Texas is forcing the Fifth Circuit to ask a question gun owners rarely hear raised in court: does Congress actually have the constitutional power to ban gun possession just because the gun once crossed a state line? In a video from Armed Scholar, the host walks through the en banc fight in U.S. v. Squire and why it's suddenly a live issue again.

Snapshot

The video covers the Fifth Circuit's decision to rehear, en banc, whether 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(1) exceeds Congress's Commerce Clause authority. Armed Scholar explains that the move follows Justice Clarence Thomas's concurrence in the unanimous U.S. v. Hemani ruling, which invited lower courts to revisit the statute, and that the case now pits defendant Curtis Squire against the Department of Justice over 1970s-era precedent.

Key points

  • The statute at stake: Section 922(g)(1) bars convicted felons from possessing firearms or ammunition, and has mostly survived Second Amendment challenges, not Commerce Clause ones.
  • Thomas's nudge: Armed Scholar notes Justice Thomas's solo concurrence in Hemani questioned whether a gun's past interstate travel can justify federal power over purely local possession forever.
  • Squire's argument: He contends a firearm sitting in someone's home fits none of the recognized Commerce Clause categories and that the 1977 Scarborough precedent decided statutory scope, not constitutional authority.
  • DOJ's pushback: The government argues Scarborough controls, that only the Supreme Court can overrule it, and that the law's interstate nexus requirement already distinguishes it from the statute struck down in Lopez.
  • What's next: Oral arguments are calendared for the week of January 18th before the full Fifth Circuit.

Quick take

Armed Scholar lays out both sides clearly without predicting a winner, which is the right call given how unsettled this is. Worth watching if you want to understand how a felony possession case could ripple into broader questions about federal power.

Watch the full video: Armed Scholar