Colion Noir Presses Longtime AR-15 Ban Advocate to Define "Assault Weapon
Colion Noir pulls a clip from a 2021 Newsweek-hosted debate between himself and John Rosenthal, co-founder of Stop Handgun Violence, who has spent decades pushing to ban so-called assault weapons. After Rosenthal claims the Heller decision only covers founding-era single-shot guns, Colion pushes back and asks him to actually define what an "assault weapon" is.
Snapshot
Rosenthal answers by pointing to the AR-15 used at Sandy Hook, arguing the .223 round is built to tumble and kill rather than hunt. Colion counters that he has hunted with .223 himself, eaten the meat, and that Heller protects firearms in common use, not just historical muskets, citing lower courts that have applied that ruling to so-called assault weapons.
Key points
- The challenge: Colion, who says he trained as a constitutional attorney, asks Rosenthal directly to define "assault weapon" after years of advocating to ban them.
- Rosenthal's answer: He calls the AR-15 a military-style weapon, references the Sandy Hook shooting, and says the .223 round is designed to injure people rather than game.
- Colion's rebuttal: He says he has hunted with .223 and eaten the meat, pushing back on the idea the round has no sporting use.
- Heller argument: Colion argues the decision protects guns in common use today, not just single-shot firearms from the founding era, and says lower courts have applied it that way to assault weapon bans.
- Side debate: The two also clash over background checks, with Rosenthal pressing on private sales and Colion raising concerns about a national gun registry leading to confiscation.
Quick take
This is a straight debate clip, not a demo or review, but it lays out the core legal and rhetorical fight over assault weapon bans in under a few minutes. Worth watching if you want to see how the common-use argument under Heller gets applied in real time against someone who's spent his career on the other side of it.
Watch the full video: Colion Noir