Gun News

Winchester Gutted Gun Ban Before Ruling, FOIA Shows $37K Cost

November 17, 2026

Winchester, Virginia, fought to keep guns banned in its public parking garages for more than two years, then quietly dropped the garages from the ban right before a judge could rule on whether it was legal, and new FOIA records show the fight cost taxpayers over $37,000.

Snapshot

AmmoLand's John Crump obtained Virginia FOIA records showing the City of Winchester paid its outside defense firm, McGavin, Boyce, Bardot, Thorsen & Katz, P.C., $35,862.78 across seven checks in the Hyland v. City of Winchester lawsuit. Add the city attorney's own billed hours and total legal payments reach $37,172.78, spent defending a parking garage gun ban that the city itself gutted before trial.

Key points

  • The lawsuit: Patrick Hyland, backed by the Gun Owners Foundation and the Virginia Citizens Defense League, sued over Winchester's ban on firearms in city parking garages, and a June 2024 agreed order already blocked enforcement.
  • The payments: Seven checks to the defense firm ran from August 2024 through June 2026, with the two largest at $10,630.32 and $9,947.80.
  • The missing paperwork: The city attorney's own invoices list hourly rates and time entries, but when asked for the same detail on the outside firm's $35,862.78, the city said it has "no additional responsive documents."
  • The retreat: In May 2026, Winchester amended its ordinance to exempt public parking structures, and on May 26 the court dismissed the case as moot without ruling on constitutionality.
  • The reaction: Gun Owners of America's Erich Pratt told the Daily Caller News Foundation the city "saw the handwriting on the wall" as deposition of the police chief approached.

Quick take

This is the second time Winchester's council has rewritten a gun-free-zone ordinance rather than let a judge decide it, and the records raise a real question about accountability for public legal spending, not just gun rights.

Read the full story: ammoland.com