Supreme Court Leaves Mixed Maryland 'Sensitive Places' Ruling Intact
The Supreme Court declined to hear Novotny v. Moore on Monday, leaving the Fourth Circuit's ruling on Maryland's "sensitive places" gun restrictions in place, a decision Bearing Arms editor Cam Edwards says keeps a host of questionable gun-free zones on the books.
Snapshot
Maryland's post-Bruen law bans carry in a range of locations, and the Fourth Circuit upheld bans in museums and certain state buildings while flagging restrictions on parks, forests, and entertainment venues as constitutionally shaky. By denying cert, the Supreme Court leaves that mixed ruling standing rather than settling the bigger question of how far "sensitive place" laws can reach.
Key points
- Mixed appellate ruling stands: The Fourth Circuit upheld Maryland bans in museums and some state-controlled buildings but found bans on parks, forests, and entertainment venues legally vulnerable under Bruen's historical-tradition test.
- Thomas writes separately: Justice Clarence Thomas said he doubts every Maryland statute matches the nation's historical tradition of firearm regulation, but agreed cert should be denied because the case bundled too many distinct laws together.
- Other states named: Edwards points to New Jersey's 25 restricted locations, New York's 20, and California's 29, including libraries, zoos, casinos, places of worship, and athletic facilities, as similar sprawling "gun-free zone" lists.
- Possible next vehicle: Edwards flags Christian v. James, a challenge to New York's park-carry ban, with New York's opposition brief due December 3, as a case that could draw the four votes needed for cert.
- Related denial: The Court also denied cert in Colie v. Commonwealth of Virginia, leaving intact Alan Colie's conviction on a single discharge charge despite his acquittal on other counts tied to shooting a YouTube prankster who confronted him.
Quick take
Edwards argues the Court's piecemeal approach is a mistake. He contends that letting states stack dozens of "sensitive place" bans without a broad ruling means gun owners could spend decades fighting each restriction one lawsuit at a time, even as the cumulative effect guts the right to carry throughout an ordinary day.
Read the full story: bearingarms.com