Gun News

First Circuit orders new Bruen test for DUI gun ban case

November 16, 2026

A New Hampshire man blocked from buying a gun over two old DUI convictions just got a second shot at his Second Amendment challenge, after the First Circuit ruled that the precedent courts used to shut down these cases no longer applies.

Snapshot

On November 13, 2026, the First Circuit vacated the dismissal of Thomas Marshall's lawsuit over a federal firearm prohibition tied to DUI convictions from 1997 and 2005. The court sent the case back to a New Hampshire federal judge, ordering a real historical analysis under the Supreme Court's Bruen framework instead of reliance on older circuit precedent.

Key points

  • The convictions: Marshall's two Massachusetts DUI convictions each carried a potential sentence of up to two and a half years, putting him outside the federal exception for minor misdemeanors and making him a prohibited person under 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(1).
  • The old precedent falls: Chief Judge David Barron wrote that the circuit's 2011 Torres-Rosario ruling "no longer controls" in light of this year's Levasseur decision, meaning Bruen's text-and-history test now applies to these challenges.
  • Purchase, not possession: The court let Marshall's challenge to his firearm purchase denial move forward, but found he lacked standing to separately challenge criminal prosecution for possession.
  • DOJ's restoration process looms: The panel told the lower court to weigh the Justice Department's new § 925(c) relief process, under which the Attorney General had reportedly granted relief to 22 people as of February 2026.

Quick take

Nothing here restores Marshall's gun rights or strikes down the federal ban. What it does is force the government to actually defend using decades-old DUI convictions against the Constitution's historical tradition, rather than hiding behind a pre-Bruen rule. For gun owners across Maine, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, Rhode Island and Puerto Rico, that's a door worth watching.

Read the full story: ammoland.com