Major Gun Ruling Stuns Court
The Sixth Circuit just ruled that the federal ban on gun possession for people adjudicated "mentally defective" survives Second Amendment scrutiny, and the case behind it involves a man pulled over near Fort Knox wearing body armor with eight guns, fentanyl and a gas can in his car.
Snapshot
On October 29, 2026, a Sixth Circuit panel led by Judge Eric Murphy upheld 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(4) against a facial challenge from Alexander Laykovich, who was convicted after being caught with firearms despite a prior Missouri court finding him dangerous. The court ruled the law passes the Bruen test because history shows society has long restricted the liberty of the severely mentally ill.
Key points
- The backstory: Missouri courts detained Laykovich in 2023 for 21 days after finding his mental illness created a serious risk to himself or others, and barred him from guns.
- He never appealed: Laykovich could have petitioned to lift the ban by proving he was no longer a danger, but never did.
- The arrest: In January 2024, Kentucky officers stopped him near Fort Knox and found eight firearms, ammo, knives, a gas can, marijuana and a fentanyl pill; he claimed he was headed there over a "clearance" dispute.
- The ruling: The court found he's still part of "the people" under the Second Amendment, but historical commitment laws for dangerous individuals count as a valid analogue under Bruen's "how and why" test.
- What's left unresolved: The court admitted the law doesn't clearly define what mental illness qualifies as "defective," but didn't have to address that since Laykovich's challenge was facial, not as-applied.
Quick take
Tom Knighton at Bearing Arms says he's torn on this one. He notes the Second Amendment doesn't carve out exceptions for "certain people," yet society has always confined those too dangerous to trust with anything sharper than a spoon. His bigger worry is the vagueness problem: without a hard definition of what adjudication actually means, this ruling could eventually get stretched to cover red flag laws far beyond cases like this one.
Read the full story: bearingarms.com