NYPD's Gun-Melting Video Hides the Real Recidivism Problem
Colion Noir takes aim at an NYPD promotional video showing seized firearms being melted down, arguing the cinematic treatment of guns in a furnace conveniently leaves out the people those guns were taken from.
Snapshot
In a video from Colion Noir, he breaks down NYPD footage of thousands of confiscated guns being trucked to a plant, dumped, and melted into molten steel set to dramatic music. Noir argues the piece frames the firearms themselves as the threat while never mentioning the arrests, case files, or outcomes tied to the people who actually carried them.
Key points
- The video: Noir walks through the NYPD's wordless clip of racked guns, a box truck escort, and molten metal pouring from a ladle, captioned "never to cause harm again."
- Commissioner's quote: He cites NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tish telling ABC7 New York that 4,500 seized firearms "can no longer be used to target our communities," which Noir says still skips the people holding them.
- Adams' admission: Noir quotes former Mayor Eric Adams saying he'd challenge anyone to find a seized gun whose owner hadn't already had some prior run-in with the criminal justice system.
- The rearrest stat: He references a 2022 statement from Governor Hochul's office noting one in four people arrested for gun crimes are rearrested, paired with ABC7's figure of roughly 4,000 NYPD gun arrests a year.
- Arizona comparison: Noir contrasts New York's approach with Arizona law, which requires adjudicated confiscated weapons to be sold to licensed dealers rather than destroyed.
Quick take
Noir's core argument is that New York's melting ceremony is theater that lets officials claim a win on paper while sidestepping whether the actual offenders stayed off the street. He's not disputing that some seized guns were junk or needed as evidence, but he says the messaging choice matters, and it points attention at metal instead of outcomes.
Watch the full video: Colion Noir