Maine Restores Four States to Carry Reciprocity, Offers No Explanation
Four states quietly vanished from Maine's concealed carry reciprocity list, and now they've just as quietly reappeared, with Maine State Police never explaining either move.
Snapshot
Bearing Arms writer Tom Knighton reports that Arkansas, Indiana, South Dakota and Tennessee have been restored to Maine's official reciprocity list after being dropped without explanation. Knighton argues the removal never squared with Maine law in the first place, since all four states had continued honoring Maine's permits the entire time.
Key points
- States restored: Arkansas, Indiana, South Dakota and Tennessee are back on the Maine State Police reciprocity list after disappearing from it last month.
- No explanation either way: Knighton says the Maine State Police Weapons and Professional Licensing Unit told him it would look into the removal, then never followed up, and the restoration went unannounced as well.
- Law didn't change: Knighton points out Maine's recognition runs on a statute requiring the state to honor permits from any state that honors Maine's, not on negotiated deals state police can alter at will.
- Nobody lost reciprocity legally: Because the four states never stopped recognizing Maine's permit, Knighton argues carry rights from those states were never actually void, regardless of what the public list showed.
- Still unanswered: USA Carry's Luke McCoy also got no response from Maine officials, leaving open whether this was a clerical error or something more deliberate.
Quick take
Knighton frames this as either sloppy bureaucracy or a quiet attempt to discourage out-of-state carry, and he's rightly uneasy that a state agency can scrub names off a public list with zero accountability. For permit holders, the lesson is to lean on the actual statute, not just whatever a state website happens to show that week.
Read the full story: bearingarms.com