Gun News

Adler Defends Heller's "Dangerous and Unusual" Quote Against NYT Claim

November 22, 2026

A New York Times piece accused the Supreme Court of basing its Second Amendment test on a misquote, and The Reload brought in William and Mary law professor Jonathan Adler to pick apart whether that charge actually holds up.

Snapshot

The episode digs into The Times' claim that Justice Antonin Scalia misquoted historian William Blackstone in District of Columbia v. Heller by writing "dangerous and unusual" weapons instead of Blackstone's "dangerous or unusual." Jonathan Adler argues the paper misread how the Court cites sources, and he says the dispute matters because it could shape how judges handle the pending AR-15 ban case.

Key points

  • The core dispute: The Times says Scalia swapped Blackstone's "or" for "and" in Heller, changing the legal meaning of the historical restriction on weapons.
  • Adler's defense: He confirms Blackstone used "or," but argues Scalia was synthesizing language from multiple historical writers who used "and" and "or" interchangeably, consistent with Supreme Court citation style.
  • A clerk weighs in: Adler says one of Scalia's former clerks told The Times it misunderstood the Court's citation rules and mischaracterized the justice's argument.
  • The Times doubles down: Despite Adler's rebuttal in Reason, the paper stood by calling it a misquote, which Adler calls unacceptable given the clerk's explanation.
  • Beyond the quote fight: The hosts also cover the Court declining to hear a challenge to Maryland's broad gun-free-zone law, with Justice Clarence Thomas reportedly outlining how a stronger future suit could be brought.

Quick take

This is inside-baseball for Second Amendment watchers, but the stakes are real: how courts read Heller's "dangerous and unusual" language could decide whether AR-15s survive future bans. Adler makes a detailed case that the Times got the citation convention wrong, and the episode is worth it for anyone tracking where that fight heads next.

Read the full story: thereload.com