Gun News

ATF Destroyed Pardoned Pastor's Guns, Wants Proof It Happened

November 19, 2026

A presidential pardon can clear your record, but it can't un-destroy your guns, and that's exactly the position Oklahoma pastor Russell Fincher is in right now.

Snapshot

Bearing Arms reports that ATF Director Robert Cekada told Pastor Russell Fincher this week that the agency destroyed all of his seized firearms, more than 50 guns total, even though President Trump has since pardoned him. Fincher says he wants proof the destruction actually happened before he accepts it.

Key points

  • What was seized: The ATF took over 50 of Fincher's personal firearms, including a Wilson Combat, five Glocks, and a mint Polytech Pre-ban milled under-folder AK worth thousands of dollars.
  • The claim: ATF Director Robert Cekada told Fincher this week that staffers destroyed every single one of the seized guns.
  • Fincher's doubt: Fincher says he's not doubting Cekada personally but wants evidence, telling Bearing Arms, "show me the video," and noting that "people tell him what they think he wants to hear."
  • Timeline conflict: Accounts of when the destruction occurred conflict, placing it in either June or August 2026, and it's unclear whether the process was recorded.
  • FOIA filed: The Second Amendment Foundation has filed a FOIA request seeking records related to the destruction.

Quick take

Bearing Arms' Tom Knighton argues the real outrage isn't that Fincher was convicted, it's that the ATF ever had the authority to destroy property it didn't own outright. Fincher could have designated someone outside his household to hold the guns until his pardon came through. Instead, a pardon that was supposed to make him whole now runs into a federal agency that may have torched the evidence of what it took.

Read the full story: bearingarms.com