75-Year-Old Wisconsin Man Shoots Intruder Forcing His Way Into Home
A 75-year-old Wisconsin man shot and killed an intruder trying to force his way through his front door early in the morning, just minutes after the same man had reportedly barged into an elderly neighbor's home.
Snapshot
The shooting happened around 1:06 a.m. on November 15 in Cassian, Oneida County, Wisconsin. According to the Oneida County Sheriff's Office, homeowner Marshall Robinson, 75, fired on 35-year-old James Roath after Roath grabbed Robinson's glasses and tried to push past him into the house. Roath died at the scene despite lifesaving efforts by deputies and EMS.
Key points
- Prior incident: An elderly neighbor called dispatch around 1:04 a.m. saying an intoxicated man had entered her home; she got him outside and locked the door, but he reportedly kept pounding and kicking it before leaving.
- Confrontation at Robinson's door: Roath allegedly moved on to pound on the side of Robinson's house, then found the front door, where Robinson met him holding a handgun.
- The shot: Investigators say Roath grabbed Robinson's glasses and tried to force his way through the doorway, prompting Robinson to raise his handgun and fire.
- Unanswered questions: Authorities haven't said whether Roath was armed, how many rounds were fired, or whether he crossed the threshold before being shot.
- Status: No arrest has been made; the sheriff's office is sending its findings to the Oneida County District Attorney to decide on charges, if any.
Quick take
This is a straightforward home-invasion scenario, an elderly homeowner facing a much younger, aggressive stranger in the middle of the night with no time to call for help first. AmmoLand's Duncan Johnson frames it as a reminder that the right to armed self-defense doesn't depend on physical strength or waiting on police response times. Whether the shooting was legally justified is now up to prosecutors, but the sequence of events, an intruder already displaying aggressive behavior at a neighbor's home minutes earlier, is worth watching as it moves through review.
Read the full story: ammoland.com