Why Two Self-Defense Shootings Cleared—But for Different Legal Reasons
Two armed citizens pulled the trigger in self-defense this fall, but only one of them walked away without a prosecutor's shadow hanging over him, and Cam Edwards at Bearing Arms breaks down why the sequence of events, not just the fact that a gun was used, decided each outcome.
Snapshot
Edwards compares a Detroit carjacking where a victim shot two armed suspects after being forced to his knees, with a Missouri road-rage case where a driver fatally shot a man who approached his car after a heated exchange. Both shooters avoided prosecution, but Edwards argues the second case only cleared because of what happened in the final seconds, not because of anything that came before it.
Key points
- Detroit carjacking: Two suspects in their 20s forced a victim and a companion out of a Hyundai Elantra at gunpoint; when one suspect told the other to shoot them, the victim drew his own gun and shot both, killing one and hospitalizing the other.
- Missouri road rage: 59-year-old Vance Townes reportedly honked, yelled and tailed a slower driver before both men pulled into a lot; police say the other driver fired five shots from inside his car after Townes approached holding a handgun, killing him.
- No charges either way: St. Louis prosecutors declined to charge the surviving driver, calling the self-defense elements "insurmountable," a decision attorney Jay Kanzler says a prosecutor was obligated to make given the law.
- Bad decisions, legal right: Edwards notes the Honda driver arguably made things worse by driving into the lot instead of leaving, but says that choice didn't erase his right to defend himself once Townes approached armed.
Quick take
Edwards' point is straightforward: carrying a gun doesn't automatically make a shooting legal, and the moments leading up to the confrontation matter as much as the shot itself. Both cases ended without charges, but for very different reasons, and Edwards argues de-escalation could have prevented the second one entirely.
Read the full story: bearingarms.com