Colion Noir Answers the ATF's Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms Question

Colion Noir is reacting to an Instagram clip from the Anti-Fud Club that's been making the rounds in gun circles, and he spends his video agreeing with most of it while pushing back on one part. The creator argues gun owners are celebrating recent ATF moves on short-barreled rifles, shotguns, and suppressors while forgetting the ATF also covers alcohol and tobacco, two products with no constitutional protection that kill far more people than firearms do.

Key points

• The numbers she cites: tobacco is roughly 10 times more likely to kill you than firearms, and alcohol about 3.7 times, with those ratios climbing to 25-to-1 and 9-to-1 once suicides are excluded from firearm deaths.
• Her core question: why does the one item in the ATF's name that's actually a constitutional right require background checks and waiting periods, while alcohol and tobacco sit on gas station shelves.
• Noir's answer: a large segment of the country values guaranteed safety over constitutional rights, and decades of slow cultural pressure built today's gun laws one restriction at a time.
• Where he disagrees: he credits recent wins, like the Bruen decision and the ATF's NFA enforcement shift, to specific Trump-appointed justices and agency leadership, not just cultural momentum.
• His closing point: voting put people in positions that moved policy, and he warns those gains could reverse with the next administration or Supreme Court vacancy.

Quick take

Noir treats this as two allies comparing notes rather than a disagreement, and that framing makes the video worth watching if you want the hypocrisy argument paired with the political mechanics behind why it's finally shifting.

Watch the full video: Colion Noir