A Toledo Woman's Shotgun Ended a Family Fight Without a Shot

Colion Noir breaks down a Toledo police report in which a 19-year-old woman grabbed a shotgun to defend her family from two men accused of turning a family dispute into a drunken, armed confrontation inside her home. He argues the case guts the familiar claim that guns are more likely to be used against someone you know than against a stranger.

Key points

• The incident: Toledo police responded early Tuesday to a home on Pinewood and found a woman holding a shotgun on a 21-year-old man and his brother.
• The charges: the 21-year-old faces charges of domestic violence, assault and using weapons while intoxicated. Noir notes these are still allegations.
• No shots fired: Noir says drawing the shotgun alone stopped the threat, which he argues is how most defensive gun uses play out.
• The undercounted stat: he points to CDC estimates ranging from roughly half a million to two and a half million defensive gun uses a year, most never reported or covered.

Quick take

Noir uses a barely covered case to make the point that pulling a gun and not firing it is still a defensive gun use, and that those stories rarely get counted.

Watch the full video: Colion Noir